Liquid liner is kind of my thing. I wear it almost daily, and it’s the eye makeup I feel most comfortable in. Over the years I have tried many differed brands and formulas, always searching for something better. Right now I am rotating between three different liners that each have their own selling features and drawbacks. Let’s jump in to it!
Maybelline Line Works Waterproof Liquid Liner $9.39 (At Shoppers Drugmart and online)
This is one that I have repurchased a few times, it’s like my old faithful. It has a slightly flexible felt tip, and the formula is blackest black which I love. I have oily lids so I do notice a bit of smudging later in the day, but this one does not flake off which is awesome. Because the tip is so fine you can get a really thin delicate line with it.
Rimmel ScandalEyes Waterproof Gel Eyeliner $10 (at Shoppers Drugmart and other Drugstores)
I just bought this for the first time a few weeks ago and I really like it! It gives a thicker line than the felt tip, and the gel really stays put. The formula is velvety but can be a little tacky while it’s drying. This is great for more dramatic winged liner, and certainly lives up to being waterproof!
Mirabella Magic Marker Eyeliner $22 (in select salons or online)
This was a Christmas gift from my Mom and I was super excited to try it out. Positives are that the marker tip allows you to have a ton of control while applying, also it’s paraben-free. The downside is that the colour is a bit sheer and not as black as I normally like my liquid liner. It’s my go-to when I am a serious rush as I can literally swipe this on in two brush strokes, and because it’s a bit sheer you can’t really notice if it’s not perfect!
Left to right: Maybelline Liquid Liner, Rimmel Gel Liner, Mirabella Magic Marker
In my ongoing search for the best liquid liner, I still think Maybelline wins. It’s super dark, and the felt tip allows you to get really fine or thicker lines depending on what look you want. I like to switch back and forth between different ones, but overall I think Maybelline has it all!
What is your favourite liquid liner? Any suggestions on what I should try next?
Beyond Blush says
I really love MAKE UP FOR EVER’s and Stila’s liquid liners
I need to try out Maybelline’s formula though, it’s so much cheaper!
http://www.beyondblush.com/2014/03/mary-kay-at-play-lip-crayon-coral-me.html
Megan Joy says
I’ve never tried MUF but I love their Aqua Eyes pencil liner!
Kalyn says
Wow…that Maybelline liner is intense! I wasn’t expecting it to be that rich, especially given the price point. I wear liquid liner almost every day…I may need to check that out.
Megan Joy says
Totally! The Maybelline liner is super dark and pigmented. I was surprised too considering it’s such a great price point.
Natalie Heather says
Wow, that Maybelline Liquid Liner is really gorgeous. The Rimmel one is nice as well, but I think Maybelline really wins in this category – especially considering the price! Great review!
Megan Joy says
Thanks Natalie! It really is great for the price point
Sarah says
I’ve only tried marker-style liners, but this makes me want to try another style since the others look so much more crisp.
Megan Joy says
Let me know if you try something new!
Jasmine says
I don’t like liquid liners, they always dry so crinkly but I do love gel liners. My favorite one is a brown from Maybelline’s StudioEye line.
Megan Joy says
I do find that “crinkly” problem with a lot of liquid liners, or they just flake off. Worst!
Julie says
I love the Kat Von D tattoo liquid liner!
Megan Joy says
I have a Kat Von D shadow palette that I love! I will check out her liner for sure
jenn f says
i’m too afraid of liquid liner hahah. i love pencil. and get along with gel but…i still can’t do a line using liquid!!! i’ll have to try some of these out to get rid of my fears.
Megan Joy says
It can definitely be tricky sometimes that is for sure! Give it a try sometime, you might surprise yourself
Chantal says
Liquid liners are one thing I have not tried yet. I do have some here in my stash so I need to take them our for a test ride.
Megan Joy says
Totally! Practice makes perfect, it took me a long time to feel comfortable using liquid liner but now I love it
Zoe says
I just tried an Essence Liquid Liner and it’s fantastic! For like $3 I definitely recommend giving it a shot because I’d love to know what you think! My first time applying liquid liner of course I’m taking photos for a blog post… wish I could have gotten it as perfect as yours
Megan Joy says
You are a girl after my own heart! That was going to be my 4th addition to this post but I didn’t want to make it too long lol I love that liner! And for $3 you can’t go wrong!
Carly says
I’ve been using Essence Extra Longlasting Eyeliner Pen too! For under $5 you can’t go wrong!
Megan Joy says
It’s so true, Essence products are great price and quality. They have a dupe for the Ciate caviar nails for under $4!